TwitterFacebookPinterestGoogle+

[OPINION]: Central Florida’s Regressive Prosecutor

In 2016, Central Florida elected Aramis Ayala as Florida’s first African-American State Attorney. Given her background and the backing of the George Soros funded PAC, Florida Safety & Justice, she was expected to be, and portrayed herself as, a progressive-minded prosecutordedicated to improving the criminal justice system.

Yet, while other progressive-minded prosecutors have embraced “smart justice” policies such as decriminalization, problem-solving courts, and mandatory-minimum sentencing reform, Ms. Ayala has proven to be anything but progressive and, in many respects, has adopted regressive policies.

Whereas today’s headlines are replete with stories about prosecutors nationwide foregoing low-level drug and marijuana prosecutions, you would be surprised to learn Ms. Ayala’s office not only prosecutes marijuana cases just as aggressively as her predecessors, she has actually reduced the availability of Pretrial Diversion (a first offender program that results in dismissal of the charges) in marijuana and other non-violent offenses.

Specifically, her office no longer allows offenders who possessed more than 50 grams of marijuana into Pretrial Diversion. Likewise, her office excludes offenders charged with cannabis cultivation from pretrial diversion – even if the “cultivation” was for personal use. Similarly, her office prosecutes possession of small amounts of cannabis concentrates (vape oil, cannabis-infused edibles, etc.) as felonies even though most other circuits will prosecute them as misdemeanors. And finally, her office now excludes concealed weapons offenses from Pretrial Diversion, something not done by her predecessors.

Pretrial Diversion Cannabis Cultivation Policy

And when it comes to the Pretrial Diversion program itself, Ms. Ayala has failed to reform the program in any meaningful way, continuing an antiquated program that costs hundreds of dollars, requires unnecessary treatment, and takes a year to complete once started.

More problematic, the misdemeanor diversion program currently has a minimum six-month backlog; meaning that even if a person is referred to diversion, they must wait six to nine months from their arrest just to start the program – never mind finish it. By comparison, most of the neighboring judicial circuits have implemented shorter, low-cost diversion programs that primarily consists of an online educational course and result in dismissal of the charges within six months of arrest.

To add insult to injury, Ms. Ayala’s office actively opposes the Ninth Judicial Circuit’s Pretrial Intervention program, which is a legislatively authorized problem-solving program that allows judges to place non-violent offenders into a substance abuse treatment program over the State Attorney’s objection and dismiss the charges upon completion.

This program is especially beneficial to offenders who are ineligible for the Pretrial Diversion program due to prior minor offenses or whom the State Attorney will not offer pretrial diversion (such as offenders charged with possessing more than 50 grams of cannabis and cannabis cultivation). Nevertheless, Ms. Ayala’s office has made it her office’s formal policy to object to any offender being placed into Pretrial Intervention and to even appeal many of those placements with the sole intention of preventing these minor offenders from having their case dismissed – something, not even her predecessor did.

Further, while both conservative and liberal activists alike have recognized that mandatory-minimum sentences are an ineffective byproduct of the failed war on drugs and are actively supporting Florida’s proposed First Step Act, Ms. Ayala has not come out in support of the bill.

And rather than empowering her prosecutors with the discretion to waive mandatory-minimum sentences involving low-level, non-violent offenders, Ms. Ayala has instead removed their discretion and requires her prosecutors to seek the mandatory-minimum sentence in all eligible cases – regardless of whether they involve actual “kingpins” as opposed to users just trying to fund their habit.

The only reprieve Ms. Ayala’s office offers from this draconian policy is to sign one-sided “substantial assistance” contracts requiring offenders to ensnare at least three others into committing “trafficking” level crimes. The result is an endless cycle of low-level, frequently opioid-addicted, offenders ensnaring other similarly addicted users in order to avoid mandatory-minimum prison terms.

So, while Ms. Ayala has publicly announced a few progressive sounding policies (most notably her now-retracted position on the death penalty), the truth is those announcements have proven to be all press release and little substance. Mostly, they are minor policy changes that would not actually impact the average non-violent offender that compromise the majority of prosecutions or address the very real problem of over-criminalization that plagues our criminal justice system.

The time is now for criminal justice reform and if Ms. Ayala wishes to improve the system and the lives of those it affects, she must look inward and implement meaningful policy reforms within her own office immediately:

  • Stop prosecuting every minor drug case;
  • Enlarge the availability of Pretrial Diversion;
  • Stop the petty opposition to Pretrial Intervention; and
  • Empower your prosecutors with the discretion to waive mandatory-minimum sentences.

Candidly, such policies are no longer considered progressive – they are just considered common sense.

__________________________________________________________

Author: Richard Hornsby

Orlando, Florida Criminal Defense Lawyer and DUI Attorney Richard Hornsby is Board Certified in Criminal Trial Law by the Florida Bar and represents clients throughout Central Florida in all criminal defense and DUI defense cases.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

VIDEO NEWS

National Politics

Police officer in ‘I can’t breathe’ death won’t be charged

NEW YORK (AP) — Federal prosecutors said Tuesday that they won’t bring criminal charges against…

House Democrats’ racially charged infighting escalates

An all-out racially charged fight within the House Democratic Caucus escalated Saturday when an African…

Top Puerto Rican officials resign over profanity-laced chat

SAN JUAN, Puerto Rico (AP) — Puerto Rico's Gov. Ricardo Rosselló announced Saturday that his…

U.S. Reps. Val Demings, Al Lawson, and Alma Adams Introduce HUD Inspection Act of 2019

ORLANDO, FL – Today, U.S. Rep. Al Lawson (FL-05), Rep. Alma Adams (NC-12), and Rep.…

STATE & LOCAL POLITICS

Florida's First Lady Casey DeSantis to visit First Coast High School in Jacksonville Monday

JACKSONVILLE, Fla.– First Lady Casey DeSantis will visit First Coast High School on Monday, July…

Getting to Know Orlando Commissioner Regina Hill: “It all started with a park bench.”

ORLANDO, Fla. (FNN NEWS) - If I told you it was a park bench that…

Senator Linda Stewart Urges Orlando and Orange County Mayors To Join South Miami In Sanctuary City Lawsuit

ORLANDO, Fla. – Eyeing what she sees as overreach by the federal government to combat a…

Governor Ron DeSantis Appoints Two to the Florida Commission on Ethics

Tallahassee, Fla. — Today, Governor Ron DeSantis announced the appointment of John Grant and the reappointment…

FNN SPORTS

MORE SPORTS NEWS

Pride Mount Comeback But Fall in Stoppage to Portland

PORTLAND, Ore. - Orlando Pride (2-9-2, 8 points) erased a two-goal deficit, including a 90th-minute equalizer,…

Orlando Pride to Celebrate World Cup Champions Alex Morgan, Ali Krieger and Ashlyn Harris on Tuesday Night

ORLANDO, Fla. – After helping lead the U.S. Women’s National Team to its fourth FIFA…

Joel Smeenge Named No. 24 On Jagaurs All-25

JACKSONVILLE, Fla. – Former Jaguars DE Joel Smeenge has been named No. 24 on the…

Daytona International Speedway to Launch Fireworks Extravaganza on Wednesday Night

DAYTONA BEACH, Fla. – Daytona International Speedway is going to finish its Independence Day holiday…

Philadelphia Union’s Explosive Plays Rout Orlando City 3-1 at Home

ORLANDO, Fla. (FNN SPORTS) - Orlando City wasted no time upon their return home against…

It begins: NBA free agency finally starts Sunday

Kawhi Leonard is planning meetings in Los Angeles. Kevin Durant will do the same in…

BUSINESS NEWS

MORE BUSINESS NEWS

Celebration is Chick-fil-A’s largest, single-day customer appreciation event

ATLANTA, Ga. – Get your cow costumes ready – Chick-fil-A is celebrating its 15th annual…

[WATCH] Nourishing Biologicals Launches Four-Piece Flagship Product Line

SAINT AUGUSTINE, Fla. (FNN NEWS) – Nourishing Biologicals, a science-based skin care company created to fight and…

Getting to Know Sutherlin Nissan Co-Owner “U.S. Marine”

WINTER PARK, Fla. (FNN NEWS) - “U.S. Marine,” the man who owns Sutherlin Nissan, pretty…

Trump Delays Imposing Tariffs on Auto Imports and Parts

WASHINGTON (AP) — Caught in a sprawling trade dispute with U.S. rival China, President Donald…

US to Add 30,000 Seasonal Worker Visas as Soon as This Week

WASHINGTON (AP) — The Trump administration plans to allow 30,000 more foreign workers temporarily into…

Shark Tank Star Daymond John, DWTS's Lindsay Arnold, Joey Fatone to Host Runway to Hope 2019 Gala

ORLANDO, Fla. (FNN NEWS) - Runway to Hope co-founder Attorney Mark NeJame announced on Facebook Wednesday…

ENTERTAINMENT NEWS

  • Oscar-nominated Lebanese film director Nadine Labaki, the 2019 Un Certain Regard President for the 72nd Cannes Film Festival, speaks in a special interview during Kering's "Women In Motion" in Cannes, France May 16, 2019. Photo: Patience Eding/Another Concept Magazine/Florida National News.
    CANNES, France (FNN NEWS) - 2019 Cannes Film Festival: Pioneer Lebanese Oscar-Nominated Director Talks Women in Motion (Photo: Patience Eding/Another Concept Magazine/Florida National News)

MORE ENTERTAINMENT NEWS

Disney Skyliner Takes Flight Sept. 29, 2019, at Walt Disney World

ORLANDO, Fla. (FNN NEWS) - Disney Skyliner will begin carrying guests high above Walt Disney…

The Super-Busy Person’s Guide to the Top 10 Summer Movies of 2019

ORLANDO (FNN NEWS) - Is the July Florida heat getting to your head? Need something…

South Korea’s Top 3 Entertainment Companies Face an Intense Month of Scandals

SEOUL, South Korea (FNN NEWS) - South Korea’s top three entertainment companies, YG Entertainment, SM Entertainment,…

Singer and Songwriter Darius Rucker Visits Walt Disney World Resort

ORLANDO, Fla. (FNN NEWS) - Singer and songwriter Darius Rucker poses with Woody during his visit…

‘Stranger Things’ Season 3 Will Blow You Away [Spoiler-Free Review]

Netflix hit series Stranger Things has finally released its third season, and it's just as amazing…

Toy Story 4 repeats at No. 1 over Annabelle, Yesterday

LOS ANGELES (AP) — “Toy Story 4” hung onto the top spot in its second…

LIFESTYLE, TRAVEL & TOURISM

MORE LIFESTYLE NEWS

Disney Skyliner Takes Flight Sept. 29, 2019, at Walt Disney World

ORLANDO, Fla. (FNN NEWS) - Disney Skyliner will begin carrying guests high above Walt Disney…

Before You Go: 5 Powerful Things You Must Know to Conquer College

College life can be rough, especially if you’re in a dorm or moved out on…

[OPINION] Tampering with Our Food is a Crime!

Thanks to social media, it seems a new fad or trend emerges every other month.…

Singer and Songwriter Darius Rucker Visits Walt Disney World Resort

ORLANDO, Fla. (FNN NEWS) - Singer and songwriter Darius Rucker poses with Woody during his visit…

[OPINION] Why are We Voting on Whether LGBTQ Parents Can Adopt? Let Them.

The debate for LGBTQ+ rights rages on, and whether or not they should be able…

Celebration is Chick-fil-A’s largest, single-day customer appreciation event

ATLANTA, Ga. – Get your cow costumes ready – Chick-fil-A is celebrating its 15th annual…